“What Makes Sense Next?”: Mary Ann McCarty’s Path to the Priesthood
As a teenager, Mary Ann McCarty knew she wanted to help people know and follow Jesus. She did not yet know where that calling would lead: through seminary, a Birmingham coffee shop, and youth ministry, and eventually to ordination in the Episcopal Church.

Bishop Richard Lawson and the Rev. Mary Ann McCarty after the ordination service at the Cathedral Church of the Advent
Last Thursday, October 29, she was ordained to the sacred order of priests, becoming the newest priest in the Diocese of Alabama.

“I knew I wanted to spend my life helping people know and follow Jesus,” she says of her early call to vocational ministry, though she had no idea what form it would take. She discerned her gifts and passions one step at a time, imagining work in international missions, biblical studies in higher education, or campus ministry. Through college and seminary, each chapter brought prayer and the same question: “What makes sense next?” She considered what she knew and loved, where her gifts lay, and which opportunities fit her desire to spread the gospel.
A Mississippi native, Mary Ann earned an M.Div. from Trinity Evangelical Divinity School with the expectation of a career in academia, but along the way she discovered a love for the local church and a gift for pastoral ministry. “I wanted to be up close with the people out there, not inside the walls of a lecture hall from the distance of a professor’s lectern,” she shared. Relationships, church involvement, and internships during seminary confirmed that desire.
After graduating from seminary, Mary Ann moved to Birmingham to live with friends. She began attending the Cathedral Church of the Advent while working as a barista and picking up odd jobs. The liturgy, the emphasis on Scripture, and the assurance of the gospel, shared with a community of faithful believers at the Advent, nurtured her faith in just the way she needed. She soon became the Cathedral’s Girls Youth Director and later its Director of Youth Ministries.
The call to youth ministry surprised her. Her own high school years were not her best, she says with a laugh. Yet loving teenagers and growing alongside them as they learned to follow Jesus became a true joy, confirming her call to vocational ministry in the local church.
Through years of prayer and discernment, Mary Ann came to see ordained ministry in the Episcopal Church as a fitting expression of the calling she first sensed as a teenager. She was ordained to the transitional diaconate in April 2026 and to the priesthood last Thursday. She now serves as Curate at the Cathedral, learning to inhabit the role of a parish priest. With confidence in the resurrection of Jesus Christ, she finds great joy in walking alongside people of all ages and stages of life.
“I believe the resurrection of Jesus Christ matters for us today, and I pray our churches will be formed into the image of Christ given for the sake of the world.”